Looking for advice....cooper AT3 vs Goodyear AT

I have to pull the trigger on something tomorrow morning, and I am running out of time. I can’t really delay this. I bought E1 KO2 265/75/16s and they are too much, so I have scheduled swap out first thing in the morning tomorrow.

I have narrowed it down to three options.

All 265/75/65

cooper At3 4s— great reputation from I can read but not really as aggressive aesthetically. I have never seen one in person.

cooper At3 LT/C rated. A few pounds heavier than the 4S. A little more aggressive looking. Seems to have very few reviews when compared to the XLT and 4s.. I am thinking it may be a “master-of-none” compromise


Goodyear utlraterrians AT.

Best looking option of the three. SL rated. Two examples of punctured tire on the official Ultraterrain thread here on Tacoma World. My stock Kevlar Goodyear’s were punctured twice on the streets and once on the trail. Really scared about that brand. But it’s the lightest tire, and it has otherwise great reviews.

 

Goodyear.....

bought Cooper AT3's once...SL & punctured it @ 3K miles.....

currently running Goodyear UT's & ST Maxx...LT rated

 

Thanks. I am leaning towards the Goodyear’s because of Their looks, but I feel that is the wrong reason.