Best All Terrain Tires on size 265/75/16

Im in the need of new tires for my 2019 OR Tacoma. On my list I have BfGRKO2, Open Country A/Tlll, Wildpeak AT/3W and Nitto Ridge Grappler.
I want to know your opinion on which tire are the best for you and why. Thank You!!
I already have a leveling kit on my truck so this size should fit alright.

 

I got a set of Toyo open country at3s for free in exchange for a review and some pics. They've been great. I don't generally off-road my Tacoma (I've got a 1st gen 4runner on 37s that's my off-road rig) but I did take it out to get pics and serious perspective on them when I got them. They handled great off road with great grip. Played in some sand, and climbed some decent angles up a couple dirt mounds. On road they're pretty much what I would expect from an all-terrain tire. Not loud, and great in wet and dry conditions.

I had KO2s on my 2nd gen tundra a while back. If you get E rateds they are great because they last forever! They were used when I bought the truck and put another 70k on that truck and traded it in for my current truck and they still had tread left, but were def coming due. I'd recommend that tire, and would have bought them if I wasn't offered the Toyos for free.

 

Currently running Wildpeaks and have been pleased with them. Had approximately 4 years and around 50k on them. I plan to replace with Wildpeaks again.

Ran Toyo ATII prior and liked them but after a couple of years they were terrible in the rain. This may have been fixed on the ATIII but not sure.

 

Honestly I think it has a lot to do with the type of off-road terrain you plan to encounter. I favor the e rated KO2's bc of of the harsh rocky terrain I hunt on. I've experienced rocks cutting though AT's that don't have as durable side wall and less aggressive tread. If you are doing more sand or just dirt others you named will will get the job done.

 

I have the KO2s on my truck currently; they will be replaced with Toyo ATIII in 116 load rating. They're 6 years old/35,000; I'll get another 5,000 of tread life. Don't need the insurance any longer. I was doing a lot of remote work on shale roads.
I have the Nittos on my 4runner in 265 70 17, 115 load rating; not impressed.
Falken seem hit or miss on QC.

 

Best is probably a tough qualifier. Best in the mud isnt going to be best on the highway. The best is probably a good compromise of the two. I hear the falken wildpeak are great off road and decent in the snow, but also are fairly quiet on the highway. Have yet to pickup a set. My goodyear wrangler adventures are so loud.